Differences in the Level and Correlates of Older Care Recipients’ Depression among Those Cared by Daughters and Daughters-in-law

Abstract

Some Western studies have shown that receiving care from adult children has negative effects on psychological well-being of older care recipients. It is also indicated that care recipients’ depression varies by caregiver type. This study examined the differences in the level and correlates of depression among elders cared by daughters and daughters-in-law. Especially, it tried to test if social support(emotional support and instrumental support from children, elder’s satisfaction with the filial relationship) attenuated the influence of dependency on depression in these two groups. 293 older care recipients (157 elders cared by daughters-in-law, 136 elders cared by daughters) selected from the data of 2011 Survey of Conditions and Welfare Needs of Korean Older Persons were used for chi-square test, t-test, multiple regression. Findings suggested that the level of depression was higher in elders cared by daughters than in elders cared by daughters-in-law. It was also found that the greater dependency were significantly related to higher level of depression in both groups. Finally, the harmful effect of dependency on depression was moderated by emotional support from adult children and marginally by elder’s satisfaction with the filial relationship in those cared by daughters-in-law. But, social support has no moderating effect in those cared by daughters. Based on the results, implications including attention to elders cared by daughters for their high vulnerability to depression, keeping an eye on care receiving elders with greater dependency as a high risk group for depression, increasing emotional support from adult children to reduce depression in those cared by daughters-in-law were discussed.